Best Pizza Pan And Skillet to Make Pizza At Home

​Everything is ready at your dining table. The pepper pot, tomato and chili sauce, and all your family members are waiting for the pizza inside the oven.

The oven notifies the pizza is ready. You have taken out the pizza; the pleasant smell is coming!

Alas!

The pizza comes out with a soggy bottom. The dough is inappropriately baked! All the hard work goes into vain because of a poor quality pizza pan.

Pizzas are different in types, and depending on the model, you have to determine the pizza pan. So, it is significantly essential to purchase the best pizza pan for the right pizza type.

To make your task more comfortable, we did in-depth research and came up with the 10 best pizza pans.

When you purchase a pizza pan, you will find a lot of options available, and you will become confused during that time.

Below we will go through the review of these pizza pans so that you can make a precise decision while purchasing.

You can’t bake a pizza without a pizza pan. However, this statement is not true if the pizza is a frozen one.

But in order to bake a raw pizza, you have no other choice to purchase a pizza pan and use it. Using a pizza pan, you can bake a pizza with proper care.

A good quality pizza pan evenly distributes heat in the whole area of a pizza to make it crispy. Also, all the food ingredients of the pizza get cooked correctly.

Even pizza pans come with the oven-proof feature, and they can bear high temperatures required to bake a pizza.

If you don’t use a pizza pan, you may end up with a poorly unbaked pizza. Or if you place a pizza in the oven without a pan, it can drop between the grills.

So, a pizza pan is providing a lot of benefits. And you must need a pizza pan to cook pizza.

Top 10 Best Pizza Pan Review for Pizza Lover

Here is our review of 10 best Pizza Pans to try homemade pizza effortlessly.

1. Chicago Metallic Non-Stick Pizza Pan

Everyone loves to get flat baking pizza and this pizza pan is the most suitable one to cook flay baking pizza. 

Guess what?

It has received a Chicago Deep Dish pizza pan for a reason.

Chicago style pizza requires deep dishpans, and this pizza pan is designed to make a perfect Chicago style pizza.

It comes with a 14.25” surface and made of heavy-duty carbon steel. Carbon steel made construction is offering longevity of the item. Moreover, the surface is silicone-based. And as a result, you can quickly release your pizza from the pan. Additionally, you can easily clean the pan after baking due to the non-stick feature.

However, it is recommended to give a hand-wash to the product. This way, you can get a long service from the pizza pan. Look no further pizza pan except Chicago Metallic 16124 Non-Stick Pizza Panif you are a fan of Chicago-style pizza.

The Goods

  • The strong body that will give you many years of service.
  • Easy cleaning process as the surface contains silicone coating on it.
  • The non-sticky feature will give a smooth release of the pizza from the pan.

Cons

  • Sliding a pizza from the pan is challenging.

2. LloydPans Deep Dish Pizza Pan

If you are looking for an ideal proofing pizza pan for proofing dough, purchasing the LloydPans Deep Dish Pizza Pan will be the right choice.
Why?
Because this pizza pan is designed in such a way so that it can be carried without any trouble! 

For this reason, the stacks are stable to ensure comfortability while carrying the pan. 

This pizza pan is promised to provide you commercial quality pizza at any time.


Here is the best part:
Most importantly, the pizza pan doesn’t require any pre-seasoning. It is because the pizza pan comes with the excellent pre-seasoned tuff-kite finish. And this finish adds a release coating that is eliminating the chance of any pre-seasoning. The surface is coated smoothly so that you don’t face any sticky problem.


Besides, it is made of aluminum, and we all know aluminum is a durable material. Furthermore, it is made in the USA, which is ensuring the quality of the pizza pan.

The Goods

  • Suitable for baking both thin crust and deep dish.
  • It can provide you restaurant-quality pizza.
  • Ideal in size and no additional clean up required after baking.

The Bad

  • No prominent cons are available.

3. LloydPans Kitchenware Detroit Style Pizza Pan

It is the 2nd and back to back pizza pan from the manufacturer LloydPans Kitchenware. And I know what you are thinking about right now, what’s so special about this brand!


Am I right?

Well, LloydPans has a lengthy history of providing quality kitchen products, and this pizza pan is also no exception. 


The dimension of the pizza pan is 10” X 14,” and it is 2.5” deep. This way, it has become an ideal pizza pan for commercial pizzerias.


This large and deep pizza pan is coated using non-stick material. Besides, it is PTFE-free. Impressively, pre-seasoning in this pizza pan is unnecessary, and it is ready-to-go for baking pizza. So, without any pre-preparation, you can make your dinner or evening snacks, and after baking, enjoy a delicious pizza.


Cooler than ever!


One of the best features of the item is, the pan is oven-proof. It can bear up to 700° Fahrenheit temperatures. So, the pan is an ideal solution for use with extremely hot cooking materials. It is made of cast iron, and the heat distributes to every area evenly.


The bottom line?


Whether you are a professional pizza maker or looking for a pizza pan to bake pizza, this item will be a perfect addition to your home kitchen accessories.

The Goods

  • Durably made, deep pizza pan.
  • Oven-proof characteristics.
  • Natural non-stick coated layer.

The Bad

  • Some customers complained regarding inconsistent non-stick coating.

4. Lodge Pro Logic Cast Iron Pizza Pan

​If you wish to use it for a grill or on the stove, no trouble will happen for sure. It seems it is manufactured with versatile characteristics.


It is a single pizza pan, and versatile in character.

The Lodge P14P3 Cast Iron Baking Pan 14” will allow you to prepare either pizza or any other dish without any confusion.


The build is much durable and pretty hefty, it is promised to provide you long period service. The cool-touch looped handle is offering you to handle the pan comfortably.


Because of its pre-seasoned feature, you can use the pan just after unboxing. The pizza will slide out from the pan easily, and no debris will leave behind in the pan. Moreover, the rim around the pizza pan will keep the ingredients safe from spilling on the oven bottom.


Make sense?


The pizza pan will deliver impressive heat-retention. This way, the pizza will get even heat, and the dish will be crispy from every angle.

The Gods

  • Cleaning the pizza pan is a sweating work.
  • Cast-iron made pizza pans make it much durable.
  • Versatile in character

The Bad

  • Heavy pizza pan

5. New Star Foodservice Pizza Pan

Some pizza pans are out there, which are built to save valuable time and money both.


This pan from New star is exactly that.


This pizza pan will allow you to bake and serve both. And thus, you will be able to cut down a number of steps. And finally, your productivity will increase a lot. 

Moreover, you can serve your guest without losing time and efficiently.


What’s more?


The seamless rim design is carrying the flag of durability. Due to its seamless design, you will be able to handle it safely. Besides, eliminating any debris is much more comfortable with the pizza pan. Sturdy aluminum made pizza pan will assist you in serving your guests numerous times. And the fact is, you don’t need to replace the pan several times!


It is available within a total of 7 size ranges 8” – 20”. If you are a person who is using a pizza pan daily for professional use, the New Star Foodservice 50899 Pizza Pan will be the safest choice without any confusion.

The Goods

  • Convenient in using.
  • Commercial-grade aluminum made pans ensure longevity.
  • You can accomplish preparing to serve a pizza, all steps in a single tray.

Cons

  • Unraised edge as the pizza may slips from the tray badly.

6. Calphalon Nonstick Bakeware Pizza Pan

One of the giant pizza pans listed in the review section.


Its surface is 16”, toffee colored non-sticky surface will release the pizza without making any trouble. It is designed in such a way so that the heat can distribute evenly. As a result, you will always get a brown colored pizza, cake, or cookies.

​One of the best features of the pizza pan is, it contains holes in it. These holes allow air to create a perfectly cooked crust in the home-made or store-bought frozen pizzas.


No pressure there!


The oven-proof pan remains safe up to 450°F temperature. The product is a combination of excellent durability, robust quality, and affordability. It has many silent features that make it one step ahead of its competitors. Moreover, you will simply love its non-stick finish.


Besides, the manufacturing process of this product has been treated to ensure that the prolonged high temperature of the dishwasher and detergent don’t compromise with it and can cause harm to both your health and the pizza.

The Goods

  • Oven-proof and dishwasher safe pizza pan.
  • 2X better compared to a regular pizza pan.
  • Lifetime warranty.

The Bad

  • Large size that you will face a challenge to let it fit into your oven.

7. Cuisinart AMB-14PP Chef’s Classic Pizza Pan

The Cuisinart AMB-14PP Chef’s Classic Pizza Pan is an excellent example of the best pizza pan.


Why?


It comes with a non-stick feature both at the interior and exterior. 

Due to the non-stick feature, you will have a hassle-free release of the pizza. Additionally, the cleaning process gets straightforward and time-saving too.


Listen:


Generally, regular pizza pans get dirty after the baking process. Also, the cleanup process is much complicated. Since it is non-sticky as well as dishwasher safe, you will not find much hassle to clean it properly.


The pizza pan is equipped with a perforated surface that is confirming that each of your pizza will have an ultra-crusty crust and densely rolled edges to avoid any sort of warping.


The result?


You will not face any problem if you choose to back pizza at high temperatures with this item. Also, storing it into the freezer will not be an issue.

The Goods

  • You can use a dishwasher to give it a thorough wash.
  • Non-sticky features at both sides make the pan easy to clean.
  • Compatible with high temperature.

The Bad

  • Not a travel-friendly pizza pan.

8. Calphalon 4-pack Mini Pizza Pan

Let me say this straight:


It will be an injustice if I don’t give place to the Calphalon 4-pack Mini Pizza Pan on this list.


Its features insist me to provide a place for the product.

​Most impressively, it is a set of 7- inch 4 mini pizza pan, made of silver. Your home-made pizza will get a perfect crust because of its perforation, which allows air to circulate.


And remember:


Your pizza will not warp because of its dense gauge steel core. Also, you will not find any hot spots since heat will distribute evenly in every area of the pizza. You can use the pan not only for baking pizza but also for other cookies or cake that can be prepared using it. And undoubtedly, you will always have evenly browned pizza, cake, or cookies.


Every pizza pan is interlocked in the interior parts with non-sticky layers. As a result, you can quickly release pizza and get longer-lasting service from the pan. Impressively, you will get 2X better release performance from the pan compared to Calphalon Classic Bakeware.

The Goods

  • Dishwasher-safe pizza pan.
  • Non-sticky layer entirely releases food items without any hot spots.
  • Consistent performance.

The Bad

  • Lose the nonstick surface easily

9. AmazonBasics Pre-Seasoned Cast Iron Pizza Pan

It is a product from the manufacturer AmazonBasics who has a lengthy history in manufacturing quality products. So, in terms of quality, you can’t raise your fingers.


This pre-seasoned pizza pan delivers you multiple benefits. 

Starting with the oven-proof feature, you can bake the pizza with the pizza pan by 500°F. Even after baking, you will not get any hot spots on the pizza.


Also, food will receive consistent heat at its every portion. Thus, you will have mouth-watering brown color food items.The pizza pan's surface is 13.5” made of heavy-duty cast iron material confirms excellent holding capacity.


Good for you!


With its versatile character, you can prepare basic baking, roasted vegetables as well as breadsticks. Once cooking is finished, the user-friendly handle will allow you to lift the pan easily and carry it. Additionally, only hand wash is enough to keep the pan clean.

The Goods

  • Suitable for different food items.
  • 13.5” large surface.
  • Ensures even heat in every area of the food item.

The Bad

  • Bulky pizza pan.

10. AirBake Nonstick Pizza Pan

​Although the AirBake Non-Stick Pizza Pan receives 10th position in the list, it has many unique features to compete with the top products.

Here is why:

With this pizza pan, you can bake 12.75” pizza that will not get any hot spot for sure. 

It comes with unique Micro-Dome technology that will impressively reduce the baking time.

Compared to any other pizza pans, it will take 15% less time to bake a pizza.

The stuff is made of heavy-duty aluminum steel, which will save your pizza from burning. Moreover, its non-sticky feature ensures you can release pizza from the pan effortlessly. Also, you will have a hassle-free cleaning session.

And guess what?

Its perforated surface will ensure free airflow. More interestingly, the pizza pan comes with 10-years of warranty. It is available in 2 colors: brown and grey. If you are facing continuous burning pizza from your pizza pan, don’t look for any other pizza pans except AirBake Non-Stick Pizza Pan.

The Goods

  • Perforated surface.
  • Safe from the dishwasher.
  • Delivers evenly crusted pizza.

The Bad

  • Good weight.

Pizza Pan with Holes vs. No Holes

When anyone purchases a pizza pan, this is the first question popped up in their mind.

Which pizza pan to choose? Holes or no holes?

Well, after reading this section, you will get an answer to the most common question.

Let’s have a look at the comparison between holes vs. no holes.

Style of the Surface

Pizza pan, which has holes in their bottom, is known as a perforated pizza pan.

Airflow circulates through the holes, and because of that, the pizza dough gets cooked evenly. This way, the pizza will be cooked perfectly and gets brown colored.

Moreover, the crust doesn’t become soggy as the hole enables moisture to escape.

Also, as heat can’t reach the top part of the pizza in a pizza pan without holes, the pizza gets soggy. It will be an ideal choice for those who love soggy pizza.

Versatility

A solid pizza pan comes with both baking and serving characteristics. Even slicing is also possible in a solid pizza pan. Moreover, solid pans are non-sticky.

But here is the kicker:

You can’t serve or slice pizza on a perforated pizza pan. Perforated pizza pans are best for baking only.

How to Choose a Pan for Pizza?

​Material

The majority of the pizza pans are made of durable materials like cast iron or stainless steel.

Stainless steel made pizza pans don’t require much maintenance. But your pizza may burn if you use a stainless steel pizza pan. If you are planning to purchase a pizza pan for your home, it would be best not to choose a stainless steel pizza pan.

Cast iron made pizza pans require much maintenance and hand wash after baking a pizza. They are highly durable and provide long term service to its users.

Non-sticky Feature

Although you can wash non-sticky pizza without any hassle, because you can quickly scab away cheese and other baked food items. 

But one concern is that the chemicals on non-stick pizza pans can leach on the food. This may happen because you are baking the pizza with high temperatures. And you can’t avoid this required temperature.

So, while picking a pizza pan, make sure to look at the features.

Other Features

Handles:

Some pizza pans are available with handles. As a result, you can easily carry and move the pan from one place to another comfortably.

Vents:

Vents type pizza pans allow heating the flow at every place of the pizza. If you love a crispy pizza, you should purchase a vented pizza pan. A thin-crusted pizza gets cooked more quickly in a vented pizza pan.

Edges:

Pizza pan with edges is mostly suitable for deep dish pizza. Even baking pizza with a stuffed crust will be a lot easier with edge style pizza pans.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs) About Pizza Pan And Skillet

Is a pizza pan with holes better?

Pizza pan with a hole or perforated pizza pan delivers faster heating as well as quickly backed pizza. Due to the holes, air flow spreads throughout the pizza parts, and thus baking time decreases. But a solid pizza pan takes more time to bake a pizza because of the thick surface.

Yes, if you are using a pizza pan daily, you can choose a pizza pan with holes.

How do I use a pizza pan with holes?

Follow below instructions:

1. Use cooking oil or olive oil or canola oil to spray or rub on the perforated pizza pan.

2. Take the pizza dough and roll out on the pizza pan surface as per your required thickness.

3. Leaving the edges in the pan, apply the pizza crust rolled out to the pizza pan.

4. Follow the recipe direction to back the pizza crust.

5. Once the pizza slices are backed fully, take the pizza out from the oven.

Can I put a pizza in the oven without a pan?

If the pizza is frozen, you can directly put the pizza on the oven rack without a pan. But you can’t cook raw pizza directly in an oven without a pan. Because pizza dough will fall through the gap, and it will create more mess instead of giving a crispy pizza.

THE BOTTOM LINE…..

​For us, the Chicago Metallic 16124 Non-Stick Pizza Pan is the best among all pizza pans mentioned above. Heavy-duty carbon steel body is promised to provide many years of service without any disturbance. Carbon steel is a well-known material that can distribute heat evenly. So, every time you will get nicely cooked pizza.

Moreover, to let you face the minimum hassle during the after backing process, its non-sticky features allow a person to clean it comfortably.
The manufacturer Chicago Metallic never compromises on quality. This item is also no exception. Their full line pizza pans are promised to put a smile on everyone’s face.

I believe you don’t have any questions related to pizza pans now. If you find this article helpful, share it with your family and friends. And don’t forget to comment in the comment box.

Joe Carrow
 

Product reviewer & passionate blogger. Beside writing for this blog, I spend my time crafting research based contents for HuffingtonPost, Lifehacker & Forbes!

Click Here to Leave a Comment Below 0 comments